BOMBAY HIGH COURT REPORTS  (BHCR)
1872
VOL. 9







Lakshmibai widow and another  v.  Hari bin Ravji
Ejectment Suit by Landlord - Failure to prove lease - General title - Case put forward in plaint - Alternative case - Amendment of plaint.
1872 (9) BHCR 001


Chaku Modan Isana  v.  Dullabh Dwarka
Mesne Profits - Interest on Mesne Profits.
1872 (9) BHCR 007


Yenkoba Balshet Kasar  v.  Rambhaji valad Arjun
Jurisdiction - Decree for sale of mortgaged property out of jurisdiction - Civ. Proc. Code, Sec.5
1872 (9) BHCR 012


In re N.D. Coorlawalla
Indian Insolvent Act, Secs.47, 50 and 60 - Personal discharge under Sec. 47 - Subsequent inquiry under Sec.60 - Evidence - Imprisonment of Insolvent under Sec. 50.
1872 (9) BHCR 014


The Advocate General  v.  Fatima Sultani Begam and another
Muhammadan Law - Wakf - Founder's right to appoint manager - Manager chosen from specified class - Akriba, meaning of term - Wife of founder.
1872 (9) BHCR 019


T.F. {immett, Official Liquidator of the Mercantile Credit and Financial Association (Limited)  v.  Vinayak Pandurang
Act XXVIII of 1865, Sec. 24 - Final Discharge of Trader - Liability to future calls.
1872 (9) BHCR 027


Gangji Vithal  v.  Sitaram Shridhar
Costs as between Pleader and Client - Remedy of Pleader - Quantum meruit - Regulation II of 1827, Sec.52 - Act I of 1846, Sec.7
1872 (9) BHCR 033


Mulchand, heir of Kalidas Maneakhramdeed  v.  Motichand Hargovanda's
Heirship - Certificate of Heirship - Production of Certificate.
1872 (9) BHCR 037


Utamram Maniklal  v.  Damodhardas Maniklal
Minor - Accounts of Guardian - Administration of Minor's Estate - Jurisdiction - Civil Court of District - Act XX of 1964.
1872 (9) BHCR 039


In re Keshav Kasinath
Stamp - Power of attorney - Act XVIII of 1869, Article 13 Schedule II - Act VIII of 1871, Section (a) 33.
1872 (9) BHCR 043


Nakoda Ismail valad Ahmed Barucha  v.  Kassam valad Azam Dupli
Assignment of Decree - Application for execution - Civ. Proc Code, Sec.208.
1872 (9) BHCR 046.


Framji Rustamji  v.  Ratansha Pestanji and another
Procedure - Order recognizing assignment of Decree - Final Order - Appeal - Assignee of Decree - Application for Execution.
1872 (9) BHCR 049.


Lakshmibai, widow  v.  Vithal Ramchandra
Mortgage - Limitation - Foreclosure Suit - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. I, Cl.12.
1872 (9) BHCR 053


Lakhmichand Walchand  v.  Kastur Bechar
Registration - Unregistered Deed of Sale - Registered Certificate of Sale - Priority - Act XX of 1866, Sec.50.
1872 (9) BHCR 060


Sagangowda bin Basangowda  v.  Basapa bin Chenapa
Limitation - Suit to recover land in possession of defendant - Accrual of cause of action - Evidence to be adduced by plaintiff.
1872 (9) BHCR 062.


Hari Govind Joshi, purchaser of a decree held by Krishnarav Anant Joshi  v. Ramchandra Pandurang Joshi, heir of Ganesh Ramchandra and Pandurang Ganesh, deceased.
Decree for sale  of immoveable property - Certificate of Sale - Attachment.
1872 (9) BHCR 064.


Vallabh Bhula  v.  Rama, heir of Lakha Jivan, deceased.
Suit heard and determined - Civi. Proc. Code Sec. 2 - Misdescription of document - admissions.
1872 (9) BHCR 065.


Shankarbhai Gulabbhai and other  v.  Kassibhai Vithalbhai
Mortgage - Redemption after fixed time has expired - Gahan lahan clause.
1872 (9) BHCR 069


Krishnaji alias Babaji Keshav  v.  Ravji Sadashiv and another
Mortgage - Conditional Sale - Redemption by mortgagor - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. I cl.15.
1872 (9) BHCR 079


Narayan and others  v.  Satvaji and others
Hindu Law - Mortgage - Interest exceeding principal - Damdupat - Reg. V of 1827, Section 12.
1872 (9) BHCR 083


Nanabhai Vallabhdas  v.  Nathabhai Haribhai
Special Appeal - Discovery of new matter - Review - New matter showing want of jurisdiction - Practice - Withdrawal of Special Appeal - Review by lower Court.
1872 (9) BHCR 089


Kalu bin Visaji  v.  Damodhar Govind
Execution - Sale in Execution of decree - Property wrongfully sold - Refund of purchase money by execution creditor - Execution creditor liable in damages to true owner for wrongful sale - Civ. Pro. Code. Secs. 256 -258.
1872 (9) BHCR 092


Balvantrav alias Tatiaji Bapaji  v.  Purshotam Sidheshvar and another
Hindu Law - Hereditary Office, fees of  - Immoveable property - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. I cl. 12 and 16.
1872 (9) BHCR 099


Pirjada Nasarudin  v.  Venkat Prabhu
Jurisdiction - North Kanara - Decree passed by Principal Sadr Amin - Execution of such decree - Act (Bombay) III of 1863, Secs. 6 & 7 - Act XIV of 1869.
1872 (9) BHCR 113


Jamiyatram Ramchandra  v.  Parbhudas Hathi
Hindu Law  - Creditor's right to follow assets of a deceased Hindu into the hands of a purchaser for value.
1872 (9) BHCR 116


Balaram Nemchand  v.  Appa valad Dulu, Hanmanta bin Bapu, and Mahadu bin Vithu
Registration - Reg. IX of 1827, Sec VI., Cl. I - Prior unregistered sale with possession - Subsequent registered mortgage without possession - Acts XVI of 1864, XX of 1866 and VIII of 1871.
1872 (9) BHCR 121


Manmal valad Suratmal  v.  Dashrath valad Narayan
Registration - Priority - Certificate of Court's sale - Possession - Act XX of 1866.
1872 (9) BHCR 147


Reg. v.  Lukhma Chango
Bombay Act VII of 1867, Sec.27 - Music in private house - Police Prohibition.
1872 (9) BHCR 153


In re James Hastings
Habeas corpus - Warrant - Omission to seal - Description of person to be captured - Signature - Crim. Proc. Code, Secs. 76 and 84.
1872 (9) BHCR 154


Ganprasad bin Sobharam
Crim. Proc. Code Sections 308, 404 - Judicial proceeding - Review.
1872 (9) BHCR 160


Reg.  v.  Vakta valad Lakhu
Pound-keeper - Act I of 1871, Sections 6 and 27.
1872 (9) BHCR 164


Reg.  v. Dhori Kullan
Obstructing Public Servant - Refusal of Cart to a Government officer - Ind. Pen. Code Sec. 186.
1872 (9) BHCR 165.


Reg.  v.  Sadu Dadabhai
Smuggled Opium - Appeal from decision of magistrate of District - Regulation XXI of 1827, Section 7 - Crim. Proc. Code, Sections 21 and 409.
1872 (9) BHCR 166


Reg.  v.  Papidio Muthdo
Full-Power Magistrate - Reference of cause by Magistrate F.P. to Subordinate Magistrate.
1872 (9) BHCR 167.


Reg.  v.  Subhana bin Ganu
Retrial - Power of District Magistrate to direct retrial - Crim. Proc. Code, Sec. 435.
1872 (9) BHCR 169


Reg.  v.  Venku Narsa
Acquittal of accused by Magistrate - Power of Sessions Court to direct committal - Crim. Proc. Code, Secs. 252 and 435.
1872 (9) BHCR 170


Reg.  v.  Jethya valad Vestya
Breach of contract of service - Act XIII of 1859, Sec.2.
1872 (9) BHCR 171.


Reg.  v.  Anvarkhan valad Gulkhan and another
House-breaking in order to commit theft - Compound offence - Separate sentence - Limit of punishment - Ind. Pen. Code, Secs. 380 and 457.
1872 (9) BHCR 172


Ardesar Hormasji Wadia  v.  The Secretary of State for India in Council
Appointment of third arbitrator under Sec. 12 of Act VI., 1857 - Umpire - Award - Nullity - Notice to attend - Irregularity - Misconduct - Waiver.
1872 (9) BHCR 177.


The Collector of Ahmedabad  v.  Samaldas Bechardas
Talukdari village - Purchaser from Talukdar - Bombay Act VI of 1862 - Re judicata - Decision by default - Civ. Proc. Code, Sec. 246 - Alienation of Talukdari village.
1872 (9) BHCR 205


The Justice of the Peace for the City of Bombay  v.  The Great Indian Peninsula Railway Company
Rates - Municipal ground rates - Railway Company's liability to pay rates - Principle of rating - Owner - Occupier - Act II of 1865 (Bombay) - Act IV of 1867 (Bombay).
1872 (9) BHCR 217


The Government of Bombay  v.  Gosvami Shri Girdharlalji
Reg. V of 1827, Sec. I., Cl. I - Allowance not incidental to hereditary Office - Prescriptive right.
1872 (9) BHCR 222.


Narayan bin Sidoji  v.  Davudbhai valad Fatebhai
Practice - Review of District Judge's judgment after admission of Special Appeal - Cancellation of order admitting Special Appeal - Civil Procedure Code Secs. 376, 378.
1872 (9) BHCR 238.


The Government of Bombay  v.  Ranmalsingji Amarsingji
Jurisdiction - Consent - Land situated beyond British Territories.
1872 (9) BHCR 242.


Jadav Rughnath  v.  Raiji Himmat
Registration - Act XVI of 1864, Sections 13 and 14, - Act X of 1862 - General exemptions - Surrender by a tenant to his landlord.
1872 (9) BHCR 246.


Mahadaji Govind  v.  Sonu bin Davlata
Extraordinary Jurisdiction of High Court - Power of Superintendence - Reg. II of 1827, Sec. V., Cl.2 - Stat. 24 & 25 Vict. Ch. 104, Sec.15 - Mamlatdar's Court - Act (Bombay) V of 1864.
1872 (9) BHCR 249


Damodhar Lakhmidas  v.  Gulabdas Lalbhai
Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Sec. 20 - Execution of decree - Warrant.
1872 (9) BHCR 254


Pragji Rudarji  v.  Endarji Bhimhai
Civ. Proc. Code, Sec. 7 - Joinder of different causes of action.
1872 (9) BHCR 257


Madvala bin Ginapa  v.  Bhagvanta bin Devji
Limitation - Payment - Arrears - Cause of Action.
1872 (9) BHCR 260


Shriniva's Udpirav  v.  L. Reid, District Magistrate of Dharwar; Rangrav Bhimaji, 1st Class Subordinate Magistrate, And Krishnarav Hanmant.
Privacy, invasion of - Opening new windows.
1872 (9) BHCR 266.


Suganchand Shivda's and others  v.  Mulchand Joharimal
Cause of action - Whole cause of action - Hundi - Action against indorser - Jurisdiction - Letters Patent, High Court, Cl.12.
1872 (9) BHCR 270


Gangaram Velji  v.  Parbhu Dayaram
Civ. Pro. Code Secs. 205 and 273 - Wearing Apparel - Attachment.
1872 (9) BHCR 272


Krishnaji Narayan  v.  Govind Bhaskar and others
Hindu Law - Mortgagee without possession - Suit to recover land - Mamlatdar's order aginst mortgagor - Judgment not inter partes - Bombay Act V of 1864.
1872 (9) BHCR 275.


Muhammad Yakoub  v.  Muhammad Ismail and others.
Khoti land  - Suit by Khot against cultivator - Onus of proof.
1872 (9) BHCR 278


Naro Ganesh Datar  v.  Muhammad Khan
Limitation - Implied contracts - Six years' limitation.
1872 (9) BHCR 280


Kuria bin Hanmia  v.  Gururav and others
Service Watan land - Successive life tenants - Cause of action - Practice.
1872 (9) BHCR 282


Ramabai wife of Bhikaji Bhaskar  v.  Trimbak Ganesh Desai and another
Hindu Law - Maintenance of deserted wife - Jurisdiction - Small Cause Court - Extraordinary Jurisdiction of High Court.
1872 (9) BHCR 283


Rayasangji Shivsangji  v.  Gulam Rasul and others
Jurisdiction - Appeal - Bombay Civil Courts Act (XIV of 1869) Sec. 26.
1872 (9) BHCR 286.


Vasudev Vishnu a Minor by his Mother and Guardian Ramabai  v.  Narayan Jagannath
Minor - Representation of minor in a suit - Proceeding in the nature of a suit - Award - Civ. Proc. Code, Sec. 327 - Act XX of 1864, Sec.2
1872 (9) BHCR 289.


Ardesar Jahangir Framji  v.  Avabai
Restitution of conjugal rights - Parsee Marriage and Divorce Act (No. XV of 1865), Secs. 36 and 40 - Civ. Proc. Code, Sec. 200 - Execution of decree.
1872 (9) BHCR 290


Chintaman Bhaskar  v.  Shivram Hari and others
Mortgage - Possession - Registration - Notice.
1872 (9) BHCR 304


Kalliandas Kirparam  v.  Trikamlal Gulabrai
Insolvent Court - Practice - Appeal - High Court - Notes of evidence not taken - Jurisdiction to hear appeal.
1872 (9) BHCR 307


Vijkor mother of Panachand and Tarachand minors sons of Hirachand deceased  v.  Jijibhai Vaji
Minor - Act XX of 1864 - Next friend suit by - Procedure.
1872 (9) BHCR 310


Mir Zulef Ali  v.  Yeshvadabai Saheb widow of Raghoji Angria
Sequestration - Ratification - Independent Sovereign's private property - Evidence.
1872 (9) BHCR 314


Dvarkadas Lalubhai and another  v.  George Blackwell
Practice - Insolvent Debtor's Court - Discharge of Insolvent - Opposing Creditor taken by surprise - Appeal - Reinstatement of Petition on list - Stat. 11 & 12 Vict., c.21, Secs, 56 and 73.
1872 (9) BHCR 319


W. Nicol and Company  v.  J. S. Castle
Bill of Lading - Weight contents and value unknown - Action against Master - Assignee of Bill of Lading for value - Construction - Act IX of 1856, Sec.3.
1872 (9) BHCR 321


Bai Jadav  v.  Tribhuvandas Jagjivandas and another
Trustee - Breach of Trust - Liability of passive trustee for breach of  trust by his co-trastee - Small Cause Court - Equitable jurisdiction extent of - Act IX of 1850, Secs. 25 and 32 - Act XXVI of 1864, Sec.2
1872 (9) BHCR 333


Reg.  v. Narayan Gangaram and other
Offences against opium laws - Regulation XXI of 1827 - Jurisdiction - Power of arrest.
1872 (9) BHCR 343


Reg.  v.  Garbad Bechar
Evidence - Confession - Retracting Confession - Crim. Proc. Code Section 205.
1872 (9) BHCR 344


Reg.  v.  Narayan Babaji and others
Arrest - Police - Illegal arrest - Intention - Malice - Ind. Pen. Code, Sec. 220.
1872 (9) BHCR 346


Reg.  v.  Ahone Akong
Violation of conditions of remission of punishment - Jurisdiction - Indian Pen. Code, Sec. 227 - Crim. Proc. Code, Sec. 33
1872 (9) BHCR 356


Reg.  v. Navroji Dadabhai
Evidence - Confession - Inducement - Person in authority - Practice in Criminal trials - Letters Patent, Cl. 26 - Powers of High when point of law is reserved -  Alteration of sentence - Indian Evidence Act, Secs. 24 and 167.
1872 (9) BHCR 358


Sonbai widow of Fazul Habibhai and another  v.  Ahmedbhai Habibhai and another
Procedure - Appeal to Privy Council - Interlocutory judgment - Letter Patent of High Court, Cl.15 and 40 - Intermediate appeal to High Court - Discretion - Order for Inspection of documents - Appeal from order in chambers.
1872 (9) BHCR 398.


Narayan Sadanand Bava  v.  Balkrishna Shidheshvar and others
Dahi handi ceremony - Suit to establish exclusive right to break a curd pot - Infringement of such a right - Damages.
1872 (9) BHCR 413


Bhagtidas Bhagvandas  v.  N.R. Oliver, Manager of the Broach branch of the New Bank of Bombay, Ld.
Contract - Consideration - Mutuality - Statute of Frauds.
1872 (9) BHCR 418


Vishvanathrav Kachesvar  v.  Narayan bin Gopal Khape
Bombay Act V of 1864 - Limitation - Act XIV of 1859, Sec.1, Cl.7 -Act XVI of 1838.
1872 (9) BHCR 424.


His Highness Tukoji Maharaj Holkar  v.  Pitambardas Naranji
Recognised Agent - Munim winding up firm - Civ. Proc. Code, Sec. 17, Cl.2.
1872 (9) BHCR 427


Hargopal Premsukdas and another  v.  abdul Khan Haji Muhammad
Limitation - Adjustment of accounts - Fresh starting-point - Cause of action - Jurisdiction - Letters Patent of High Court, Cl.12.
1872 (9) BHCR 429


In re The Albert Mills Company Limited. Nasarvanji Aspandiarji Manikji Hormasji and Gokaldas Madanji  v.  Shivji Manikbhai and four others
Mandamus - Company - Jurisdiction - Enforcement of Director's right by Mandamus - Casual Vacancy.
1872 (9) BHCR 438


Reg.  v.  Hargovandas and Harkissandas
Extraordinary jurisdiction of High Court - Offence not constituted by acts proved - Cheating - Indian Penal Code, Sec. 417.
1872 (9) BHCR 448.


Reg.  v.  Kikabhai Parbhudas
Defamation - Charge - Strictness of proof - Powers of High Court as a Court of revision.
1872 (9) BHCR 451


In re George Blackwell
Insolvency - European British born subject - Jurisdiction - 11 & 12 Vict., c. 21., s.5 - Letters Patent of High Court, Cl.18.
1872 (9) BHCR 461
...........................................................................................................................................................................



* * * * *