Historical Cases of Bombay High Court


PREFATORY NOTE


Many of the cases described in this Chapter are not of any great legal importance; and hardly nine or ten out of them are to be found in the Law Reports.  They are mostly criminal trials which are of interest and importance by reason of certain unusual or spectacular features, or some extraordinary circumstances which caused a stir or sensation in the general public at the time of their occurrence.  They have been selected as likely to appeal to the general reader, as distinct from lawyers.  As regards the majority of these cases, I have had to gather information from various sources.  Although there is no case in the Chapter of the magnitude and the incredibly marvellous incidents of the Bhowal Sanyasi Case, or of the diabolical cunning and merciless malignity of the Plague Bacilli Case, with the Biblical primal curse, the curse of Cain-a brother's murder-upon it, both of which came up before the Calcutta High Court, most of these cases described here are of an exceptional character; and of absorbing interest to laymen as well as lawyers, either by reason of the facts described, or some unusual features relating to their mode and course of trial.  Almost all of them, from the Rama Komathi Case in 1720, and the Maharaja Libel Case in 1862 upto Bawla Murder Case in 1925, and the Kalbadevi Shooting Case in 1946, have, in my opinion, sufficient interest to deserve a place in any series of "Notable Trials".










The Trial of Rama Komathi -1720

Maharaj Libel Case - 1862
De Ga Conspiracy Case -1873

Towers of Silence Cases - 1874
Trial of Malaharrao Gaikwad - 1875

The Crawford Case - 1880
Oppressive Litigation - 1848 - 1906

The Case of Clive Durant - 1898
First Tilak Trial - 1897         Case

Unprecedented Procedure : G.I.P. Railway Co.  Vs. Kessowji Issur - 1904-1905
Second Tilak Trial - 1909    Case

The Caucus Case - 1908
Third Tilak Trial - 1916        Case

Parsi Panchayat Case - 1909     Case
Haji Bibi  Vs. H.H.Sir Sultan Mahomad Shah Aga Khan - 1909
Case1  Case2

Nasik Conspiracy Case - 1910
Species Bank Case - 1911

A Solicitor and His Clients - 1916 : Surajmal B. Mehta  Vs. B.G. Horniman
Mullaji Case (Chandabhoy Gulla Case) - 1918-1919

De La Haye Murder Case - 1920
G.I.P. Railway Murder Case - 1921

Trial Of Mahatma Gandhi - 1922
Bawla Murder Case - 1925

"Suit For Land" " Hatimbhai Hassanali  Vs.  F.E. Dinshaw - 1927
Contempt of Court Proceedings - 1942

Kalbadevi Shooting Case - 1946 : Emperor  Vs. Mirza Abdul Majid



Note: These Historical Cases are taken from the book 'Famous Judges, Lawyers and Cases of Bombay : A Judicial History of Bombay during the British Period, By P.B. Vachha, Published by N.M. Tripathi Pvt. Ltd., Bombay in the year 1962.  This book was published on the occasion of the Centenary of the Bombay High Court.